◆ SpookStack

Declassified Document Archive & Reader
Log In Register
Reader Ad Slot
Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.

Dr. Samuel Holmes Sheppard — Part 1

60 pages · May 09, 2026 · Broad topic: Murder · Topic: Dr. Samuel Holmes Sheppard · 60 pages OCR'd
← Back to feed
eee One ee "7 Ms J. Edgar Hoover, Director, - piu <°“ Federal bureau of Investigation, _ ~" Washington, D. C. ~ ~° Movember 2, 1959s, Ue Se Dé - of Investigation, — Dear Mr. Hoover, SUBJECT: Dr. Sam Sheppard Murder Case-Cu ahoga Count _ Some time before Dr. Sheppard went on trial at Cuyahoga County - aM Court House I received information which as from a source that has been very reliable that Mrs. Sheppard was ‘killed by a left handed — man= not her husband. ; ; oe Quite some time later a criminologist from California was called in by Defense Coung#l. He stated that it was his opipfrthe veating was administered by a left handed person. a Months later I spotted a driver for Shinrock Elevator, Shinrock, ; Ohio who fitted the description of a man witnesses claimed to have .% seen near Sheppard home about time of killing. This man was both © Lo right ani left handed. I was sure I had seen the picture of this ~ man on an old flyer. a long time before. This information I turned. over to . This man was picked up an was nformed was a fugitive and returned to Florida. I understand He ‘4s the one who made an admission regarding the casée At the time of the trial, on advice of counsel, Dr. Sheppard refused to take a polygraph test. Later, I understand that the authorities refused to let Hime do so. : | | aa Several of us feel that the conviction was largely due to : biased newspaper reporting and the apparent pressure that grose a for a conviction. Co . : “. We believe, if that man and Florida is willing, both He and v : Dr. Sheppard should receive poly tests. ; ‘ Is there anything the U. & Dept. of Justice can do? I never | - knew Dr. Sheppard or any of His relatives but I do,bdgliev ere ,. may have been a miscarriage of Justice. EX 100 CC ¢ - LAE -~ J. ¢. Os ~ No correspondelle’ Brek OS bs. resident Agent’ Sandusky, Ohio knows me. : c. :
OCR quality for this page
Community corrections
First editor: none yet Last editor: none yet
No user corrections yet.
Comments
Document-wide discussion. Follow the Community Standards.
No comments on this document yet.
Bottom Reader Ad Slot
Bottom Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.

Continue Exploring

Use the strongest next step for this document: continue reading, jump to the topic hub, or move into the matching agency collection.
Continue Reading at Page 49
Jump straight to page 49 of 60.
Reader
FBI Documents & FOIA Archive
Open the FBI agency landing page for stronger archive context.
FBI
Dr. Samuel Holmes Sheppard Topic Hub
See the topic overview, related documents, and linked subtopics.
Hub

Agency Collection

This document also belongs in the FBI Documents & FOIA Archive landing page, which is the stronger starting point for agency-level browsing and for searches focused on FBI records.
FBI Documents & FOIA Archive
Open the agency landing page for introduction text, topic links, and more FBI documents.
FBI

Explore This Archive Cluster

This document belongs to the Murder archive hub and the more specific Dr. Samuel Holmes Sheppard topic page. Use these hub pages when you want the broader collection context, linked subtopics, and more documents around the same archive thread.
Related subtopics
Osage Indian Murders
42 documents · 2075 known pages
Subtopic
Atlanta Child Murders
25 documents · 2715 known pages
Subtopic
john-joseph-gotti-jr
2 documents · 53 known pages
Subtopic
Aaron Hernandez
1 documents · 114 known pages
Subtopic
alvin-francis-karpis
1 documents · 18 known pages
Subtopic
assata-shakur-joanne-chesimard
1 documents · 41 known pages
Subtopic