Reader Ad Slot
Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.
John Murtha — Part 28
Page 128
128 / 137
claimed inconsistent verdicts.
The court has carefully reviewed all of these 4
contentions and finds them an inadequate basis for the
relief sought, either taken separately or together. . The
re &
influenced. He makes a further argument with respect ta "
|
|
H
insignificance of Weinberg's credibility was discussed
® above in connection with the Myers claims. The sufficiency
. of the indictment was reviewed in a pretrial motion and
the court's reasoning in that discussion remains unchanged
by the trial events. -
7H
oo™
The claim of inconsistent. verdicts fails for
two reasons. One, inconsistent verdicts in a criminal
case do not require reversal. Standefer v. US, 100 SCt
1999 (1980). °
Two, the verdicts are not inconsistent, but easily
reconciled on this record in light of the relative participa- :"
tions of Thompson and Murphy in the events. Thompson. argues.
that there is no conceivable way in which the jury could
have found Thompson involved in duping Murphy. -If that .
“were so, then Murphy's experienced counsel wasted much
“time and his client's money in even trying this case, because >
‘his only defense to the jury was that he was not aware
Loe. that there was money in the briefcase. Other evidence
in the case demonstrated Thompson's awareness of the actual
Community corrections
No user corrections yet.
Comments
No comments on this document yet.
Bottom Reader Ad Slot
Bottom Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.
Continue Exploring
Agency Collection
Explore This Archive Cluster
Broad Topic Hub
Topic Hub
letter
bureau
Related subtopics
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic