◆ SpookStack

is adjudicating these cases and eventually result in a controversy with the G Loyalty Review Board. 5) Administrative memoranda containing various notations as to proper action which should be taken on controversial issues by various Bureau officials. : 6) Intra-Bureau communications revealing use of confidential procedures amd the identity of other Governrent agencies providing us with informtion. The characteristics noted above will also pertain generally in the case files of investigations conducted under the Voice of America Frogram, as well as those wicre we have conducted other type applicant investigations. These characteristics are, of course, in accordance with existing Bureau policy and precedure, Although the above list is not purported to be a complete list of the comtroversial types of material appearing in case files, it does present a gensral picture of the type of material contained therein which strongly evidences the necd for us to strenuously resist any efforts on the part of the Tydings Conmittee or any other Congressional Comittee to obtain our files for either public or private hearings. As you will recall, Senator beCarthy in his early appearances before the Tydings Comsittee named 9 individuals whose nares were publicized in the press, Some of these 9 imlividuals are the subjects of We have, of course, disseminated all informtion of a type that can be disseminated to the proper authorities. Particularly with respect to loyalty investigations and investigations under the Voice of Amrica | Program, the Civil Service Commission and/or the State Department already are in | possession of our investigative reports. ee, 9 ae For your information there is attached a list showing a brief analysis . on each of the 81 cases cited by Senator kcCarthy, showing the Bureau's investiga-~ tive position am the employment status of each of the individuals involved so far as our files and the records of the State Departmnt reflect. A separate list is! also attached showing an analysis of the Bureau's investigative position on the 9 , individuals mentioned by Senator McCarthy in his appearances before the Tydings | Committee whose names were publicized in the press. As you wil}-recall, these \ nmividuals were Zsther ¢ uer (and her hySband, StephayBrunauer), Gustavo ~~ Duran, HaldoreAlanson, Fhili ssup, Dorothy” Kenyon, Owen Jffattimore > Frederick yee Schumann, Jahn Stowarteierh ice and Harlow Shapley. It is noted that Esther yunauer amd Philip Jessup also are included as Case Numbers 47 and 15, respectively, in Senator MeCarthy's list of 81.