Reader Ad Slot
Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.
Supreme Court — Part 17
Page 127
127 / 130
if
4
»
0-19 (Rev. 2-2-71)
*¥
r my le Z
~étiers tothe &
Surveillance and Rights _
To the Editor:
Assistant Attorney General William
H. Rehnquist's remarks in committee
offer us an opportunity to assess how
fac we have gone and where wé are .
going op the road to Scif-enslavement.
jEditoriai March 12.)
We have already
rights sacrificed to acquiescent legis-
latures, over-eager agencies, or both
—no-knock, Army surveillance, wire-
tapping and computer dossiers are ai-
ready part of our political culture, But
“when a high Administration official .
asserts, a5 a principle of government, .
that these aspects of our citizens’ lives
‘ should be left to the sole discretion of -
the executive branch, a new element.
has been added. 7
The necessary implication of Mr.
Rehnquist's comments is that a dice
tatorship — hopefully benevolent ~
is the most appropriate form of gov-
emment for this country. ‘
If his remarks are accepted by his
listeners and by the public, then per-
haps he is right. I prefer to hope that
the other branches of Government wil] ©
offer us a safeguard for our lberties.
FREDERICK, T DAVIS |
New York, March 10, 1s7l
, Sagi ec
scen psrsonal ©
Ke
pes
rine
ee ae
Recourse to Congress
o the Editor: .
In your March 11 issue Penk Frank
Askin criticizes the recent decisions
e Supreme Court limiting ‘the
wer of the lower Federal courts to
ain state nrocesutions under alleg-—
en 7join siate proscsunons Uncer
é@
diy unconstitutional laws. Nowhere |
in his lengthy criticism, or rather de- _
nunciation, is there a word about the.
possibil: ty, open to him and those ;
who share his views, of obtaining cor-
rection from Congress.
A stranger to our polity would sup-—
pose that all these matters age ines-
capably in the hands of th
upremée
Court--an impression often oaveyed |
By commentators, especially academic _
ones. That Congress has complete con-
trol over the exercise of jurisdiction by
_the Federal district courts, and has-
express constitutional power to en-"
force, “by appropriate legislation,” the
provisions of the Fourteenth Amend. .
ment, upon which rests the imposition
on the states of what Professor Askin .
calls “constitutional vatues’—these
things are perfectly well Known to
_ him. But like so many others he ap-
’ parently prefers to seck salvation only
_ from the Supreme Court.
_ Aside from all other considerations, -
> a precise statutory definitidn of the
imitations on Federal court injunc-'
tions against state prosccutions is im-'
‘ measurably to be preferred to a doc-
trine to be extracted, if at all, so Pro-
fessor Askin tells us, only from a study
of seventeen separate opinions written
by the justices in six cases.
LEWIS LAYERS
Naur Vo, March ar
i
‘
gl?
DREW s0i dc, March amy, ouia
fo‘ i. Polson a _—
alliveas, © a So
4 *:
é Ci iohe a eel tnt
. Bishop fe 7
¢ srennan “CA:
Calluhon =
- Casper —
Co aq ately
roe 2 ae
is Gale _J
ie Rosen =
é Tavel
Walters
Soy ars
negro.
Tele. Room
Holm es
Ga
The Washibgton Post
Times Herald
The Washington Daily News:
The Evening Star (Washington)
The Sunday Star (Washington)
Daily News (New York)
Sunday News (New York)
New York Post
The New York Times
The Daily World
The New Leader
The Wall Street Joumal
The National Observer
People’s World
| MAR 241971
Date
—
. J Recs ba- 215¢5~
see ee
“Nor RE-ORDEb
LU L
19} ack } By
mee ems an
an
wey 1
Reveal the original PDF page, then click a word to highlight the OCR text.
Community corrections
No user corrections yet.
Comments
No comments on this document yet.
Bottom Reader Ad Slot
Bottom Reader Ad Slot placeholder
If you would like to support SpookStack without paying out of pocket, please consider allowing advertising cookies. It helps cover hosting costs and keeps the archive free to browse. You can change this choice at any time.
Continue Exploring
Agency Collection
Explore This Archive Cluster
Broad Topic Hub
Topic Hub
letter
bureau
Related subtopics
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic
Subtopic